Sharpe's
Challenge is a two-part series set in early 19th century India, starring
Sean Bean, and a sequel to the hugely popular 1996 series by the same
name. The original Sharpe's Challenge was set in the Battle of Waterloo.
The present programme focuses on the Anglo-Maratha wars that were
instrumental to the formation of the British Empire in India.
The film follows the fortunes of British soldier Sharpe (Sean Bean),
after his exploits in the Peninsular War against the French, which
thwarted the imperialist ambitions of Napoleon and his cohorts. In
the original series, the romanticised British soldier is shown pitting
wit and bravery against cunning enemy hordes and overwhelming immense
odds to emerge triumphant.
I expected much of the same in the present show, the backdrop of which
is the creation of the British Empire in India in 1818. The plot is
loosely based at the court of the last independent Holkar King, son
of the famous Jaswant Rao Holkar who so famously defeated the British
on so many occasions in the 1803 Anglo-Maratha War. The Maratha Empire,
of which Holkar is part, is determined to make a last attempt to vie
for the supremacy of India against the British forces backed by their
numerous Indian sepoys.
The scene shows the cruelty of casual punitive punishments at the
Indian court as they attempt to modernise their forces with the help
of French and British mercenaries. Refreshingly however many of the
British and French characters are shown equally devious and cruel
as their Indian counterparts and scenes of honour and courage are
apparent on both sides.
A further snippet of history is shown as an English mercenary, loosely
based on the 'Irish Rajah' George Thomas attempts to carve out his
own principality with the aid of the troops of the Begum Samru, an
erstwhile Mughal princess. (In real life Thomas was killed and his
so called principality faded into the fold of the Maratha Empire)
The British Indian troops are led by a Mohan Singh who exhibits character
and courage throughout the program and even whilst dying with great
dignity affirms his faith in Hindu beliefs as he tells Sharpe that
this is not the first nor the last time of him meeting death. A hint
of the anti-Indian racism and prejudice that later inflamed the Indian
soldiers to the great rising of 1857 is also shown (although needless
to say, this racism is challenged by hero of the show, Sharpe)
The film hints at the fall of the Marathas and the failure of a great
conspiracy against the British Empire, but manages to do so without
falling into the trap of pretending that a great social revolution
was taking place. In other words, the program didn't make out that
the British were 'civilising' barbaric Orientals, as so many British
dramas, films and writings make out.
There are positive affirmations of Hindu culture as the young prince
Holkar tells the general's daughter of the antiquity and depth of
Hindu culture. Also the Indian soldiers are shown firm in refusing
to perform duties that violated their sense of dharma. The soldiers
of the Holkars are also shown as Hindu soldiers fighting with courage
and determination. In fact, there were quite a few positive Hindu
inputs to the flavour of the film.
Overall not a bad effort. Sharpe was hardly likely to lose, but managed
to achieve success without mocking and condescending, unlike most other
shows about India and her history.